01 December 2010

Quote from Susan Neiman's Evil in Modern Thought

It is as shortsighted as it is condescending to explain the international rise in religious fundamentalism by suggesting that people want easy answers to the problems of a complex world. No doubt, sometimes, they do. But they just as surely want worldviews that express moral standpoints: that human dignity is a good which cannot be bartered, that some actions are so vile they cannot be redeemed. Clarity should never be confused with simplicity, moral clarity least of all. But a view that has no means to express legitimate needs for moral clarity will leave people to seek it elsewhere, and to settle for moral simplicity instead. Scruples about using moral language responsibly should lead us to use it responsibly, not to abandon it entirely - leaving moral ammunition in unscrupulous hands.

2 comments:

  1. Thanks for posting Josh. I particularly like that last line: "Scruples about using moral language responsibly should lead us to use it responsibly, not to abandon it entirely - leaving moral ammunition in unscrupulous hands."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yea, I don't know how I feel about that last line... although I imagine quite a few of the readers on here are inclined to completely agree with her. It just seems like inappropriately strong language to describe groups like fundies. I feel that they're just... rather than a fair assessment there's some overly antagonistic group dynamics going on. "Unscrupulous" belongs more along the lines of politicians and TV evangelist.

    ReplyDelete